Chicken Thighs and Gnocchi with Smoked Mushrooms & Red Peppers

Chicken Thighs and Gnocchi with Smoked Mushrooms & Red Peppers

I did manage to get three pints of various mushrooms and two gorgeous red peppers into the smoker. As a result I got a lovely dish and a very simple recipe: Chicken Thighs and Gnocchi with Smoked Mushrooms & Red Peppers. Here’s what you’ll need.


4 Large chicken thighs

1 Pint shitake mushrooms

1 Pint sliced baby bella mushrooms

1 Pint whole oyster or button mushrooms

2 Large red bell peppers

1 Tbsp bacon fat

1 Tbsp olive oil (preferably rosemary infused)

2 Cups chicken stock (more on hand)

1 16-ounce package gnocchi

10 Ounces fresh baby spinach

1 up heavy cream

2 Tbsp crushed garlic

2 Sprigs fresh rosemary

Salt and pepper to taste


Get the mushrooms and peppers smoked first. Leave all the mushrooms whole, except for the shitake stems, as they can become tough.

Then behead, remove the seeds and quarter the red peppers. Distribute them with all the mushrooms on one rack in the smoker set at 220ºF over apple wood for about 90 minutes.

The peppers should have lost their vibrant red hue, and the skin should be a bit puckered. The mushrooms should look both a little dried and darker in color, but none of the tray should look like it’s been shrinky-dinked. After all, we’re not dehydrating, merely smoking.

Remove from the smoker when done and cool, and you can certainly refrigerate the entire batch for use later. Stash them in a sealed plastic container and keep in the fridge until you decide to prepare this dish.

A Perfect Combination of Pasta, Mushrooms and Chicken

In a large sauté pan, melt the bacon fat, butter, or olive oil. Add one tablespoon of the crushed garlic and, when sizzling, lay in your chicken thighs. A little bit of chicken stock will suffice, as we just want to keep a little moisture in the pan and keep it all from spattering around.

Make sure to unfold each thigh so that each one is as flat and as much in a single layer in the pan as possible. Salt and pepper the upside if you like, let the downside brown, flip, and repeat.

Once they’re done, distribute one of the sprigs of rosemary evenly over the top of the cluck, slap a lid on the pan. and move the pan off the heat.

Herbs that Make All the Difference

In a larger sauce pan or saucier, heat the rosemary olive oil and the other tablespoon of crushed garlic to barely sizzling. Add in your gnocchi and brown evenly over a medium burner. DeLallo is my favorite because they are just the right denseness and not to heavy,

Add the leaves from the other sprig of rosemary at about the halfway point, stirring occasionally to get the pillows to a nice color, not a solid brown. We want just a nice mix of toasty brown and creamy yellow potato.

Once the gnocchi are where you like them color-wise, add in the smoked mushrooms and peppers and about a cup of the chicken stock. Stir to combine and raise the heat a bit on the burner.

Time for the Chicken

Take the chicken thighs and give them a good rough chop and add them to the sauce pan, too, along with all the liquid and scrapings in the bottom of the pan.

Stir again, adding a bit more chicken stock as necessary to keep the mixture in just a little bit of liquid, then add in the heavy cream.

Finally, lay the spinach on top - I used all of the big, 10-ounce plastic tub of baby spinach from Organic Girl - put the top on the pan, and let the spinach wilt down, maybe five minutes.

Ultimately, there should be just enough liquid in the pan to combine with the starch from the gnocchi. As a result, you should end up with a nicely sauced dish, not too loose, not too thick.

Ready to Go

Serve it up with some thick French bread and you’ve got a filling meal that’s not too heavy, not too light. One whose smoky highlights impart a richness to what would otherwise be an average casserole of sorts.